Libertarian Liberty Quotes

We've searched our database for all the quotes and captions related to Libertarian Liberty. Here they are! All 100 of them:

β€œ
Human beings are born with different capacities. If they are free, they are not equal. And if they are equal, they are not free.
”
”
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
β€œ
I love my country, not my government.
”
”
Jesse Ventura
β€œ
When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in a society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it.
”
”
FrΓ©dΓ©ric Bastiat
β€œ
Politics: the art of using euphemisms, lies, emotionalism and fear-mongering to dupe average people into accepting--or even demanding--their own enslavement.
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
The fact that so many successful politicians are such shameless liars is not only a reflection on them, it is also a reflection on us. When the people want the impossible, only liars can satisfy.
”
”
Thomas Sowell
β€œ
He who is unfit to serve his fellow citizens wants to rule them.
”
”
Ludwig von Mises (Bureaucracy)
β€œ
It is easy to be conspicuously 'compassionate' if others are being forced to pay the cost.
”
”
Murray N. Rothbard
β€œ
It's not an endlessly expanding list of rights β€” the 'right' to education, the 'right' to health care, the 'right' to food and housing. That's not freedom, that's dependency. Those aren't rights, those are the rations of slavery β€” hay and a barn for human cattle.
”
”
Alexis de Tocqueville
β€œ
We are convinced that liberty without socialism is privilege, injustice; and that socialism without liberty is slavery and brutality.
”
”
Mikhail Bakunin
β€œ
I am truly free only when all human beings, men and women, are equally free. The freedom of other men, far from negating or limiting my freedom, is, on the contrary, its necessary premise and confirmation.
”
”
Mikhail Bakunin
β€œ
The demagogue is one who preaches doctrines he knows to be untrue to men he knows to be idiots.
”
”
H.L. Mencken
β€œ
Taxation is theft, purely and simply even though it is theft on a grand and colossal scale which no acknowledged criminals could hope to match. It is a compulsory seizure of the property of the State’s inhabitants, or subjects.
”
”
Murray N. Rothbard
β€œ
Socialism is an alternative to capitalism as potassium cyanide is an alternative to water.
”
”
Ludwig von Mises (Human Action: A Treatise on Economics)
β€œ
Every socialist is a disguised dictator.
”
”
Ludwig von Mises
β€œ
The idea that you have to be protected from any kind of uncomfortable emotion is what I absolutely do not subscribe to.
”
”
John Cleese
β€œ
The world, viewed philosophically, remains a series of slave camps, where citizens – tax livestock – labor under the chains of illusion in the service of their masters.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
A tax-supported, compulsory educational system is the complete model of the totalitarian state.
”
”
Isabel Paterson (The God of the Machine (Library of Conservative Thought))
β€œ
The welfare state is the oldest con game in the world. First you take people's money away quietly and then you give some of it back to them flamboyantly.
”
”
Thomas Sowell
β€œ
If taxation without consent is not robbery, then any band of robbers have only to declare themselves a government, and all their robberies are legalized.
”
”
Lysander Spooner
β€œ
Here beyond men's judgments all covenants were brittle.
”
”
Cormac McCarthy (Blood Meridian, or, the Evening Redness in the West)
β€œ
When people have invested their identities into clichΓ©s, the only counter argument they have is 'being offended'.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
The welfare of the people in particular has always been the alibi of tyrants, and it provides the further advantage of giving the servants of tyranny a good conscience.
”
”
Albert Camus
β€œ
Emergencies” have always been the pretext on which the safeguards of individual liberty have eroded.
”
”
Friedrich A. Hayek
β€œ
The most urgent necessity is, not that the State should teach, but that it should allow education. All monopolies are detestable, but the worst of all is the monopoly of education.
”
”
FrΓ©dΓ©ric Bastiat (What Is Money?)
β€œ
Whenever someone starts talking about 'fair competition' or indeed, about 'fairness' in general, it is time to keep a sharp eye on your wallet, for it is about to be picked.
”
”
Murray N. Rothbard
β€œ
I'm not scared of the Maos and the Stalins and the Hitlers. I'm scared of the thousands of millions of people that hallucinate them to be "authority", and so do their bidding, and pay for their empires, and carry out their orders. I don't care if there's one looney with a stupid moustache. He's not a threat if the people do not believe in "authority".
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
When enough people understand reality, tyrants can literally be ignored out of existence. They can't ever be voted out of existence.
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
All utopias are dystopias. The term "dystopia" was coined by fools that believed a "utopia" can be functional.
”
”
A.E. Samaan
β€œ
Freedom is indivisible. As soon as one starts to restrict it, one enters upon a decline on which it is difficult to stop.
”
”
Ludwig von Mises
β€œ
If you can convince people that freedom is injustice, they will then believe that slavery is freedom.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
When we give government the power to make medical decisions for us, we in essence accept that the state owns our bodies.
”
”
Ron Paul
β€œ
The "right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" begins with "life", and "life" begins at conception.
”
”
A.E. Samaan
β€œ
Distraction serves evil more than any other mental state.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
Clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right, here I am -- not stuck in the middle, but hovering above the entire farcical spectrum, weeping as I behold my fellow man's devotion to political illusion and self-destruction.
”
”
Robert Higgs
β€œ
The truth is, one who seeks to achieve freedom by petitioning those in power to give it to him has already failed, regardless of the response. To beg for the blessing of β€œauthority” is to accept that the choice is the master’s alone to make, which means that the person is already, by definition, a slave.
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
Deep pockets and empty hearts rule the world. We unleash them at our peril.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
What is ominous is the ease with which some people go from saying that they don't like something to saying that the government should forbid it. When you go down that road, don't expect freedom to survive very long.
”
”
Thomas Sowell
β€œ
The worship of the state is the worship of force. There is no more dangerous menace to civilization than a government of incompetent, corrupt, or vile men. The worst evils which mankind ever had to endure were inflicted by bad governments. The state can be and has often been in the course of history the main source of mischief and disaster.
”
”
Ludwig von Mises
β€œ
No state, no government exists. What does in fact exist is a man, or a few men, in power over many men.
”
”
Rose Wilder Lane
β€œ
Democracy is a pathetic belief in the collective wisdom of individual ignorance.
”
”
H.L. Mencken
β€œ
State is the name of the coldest of all cold monsters. Coldly it lies; and this lie slips from its mouth: 'I, the state, am the people.
”
”
Friedrich Nietzsche
β€œ
Civil Wars happen when the victimized are armed. Genocide happens when they are not.
”
”
A.E. Samaan
β€œ
People ask me what I am politically and I've previously offered this equation: I became a conservative by being around liberals. And I became a libertarian after being around conservatives.
”
”
Greg Gutfeld (The Joy of Hate: How to Triumph over Whiners in the Age of Phony Outrage)
β€œ
Every step which leads from capitalism toward planning is necessarily a step nearer to absolutism and dictatorship.
”
”
Ludwig von Mises (Omnipotent Government)
β€œ
Liberty means refusing to allow some men to use the state to compel other men to serve their interests or opinion.
”
”
Auberon Herbert
β€œ
The more laws and restrictions there are, The poorer people become. ... The more rules and regulations, The more thieves and robbers.
”
”
Lao Tzu
β€œ
It is in war that the State really comes into its own: swelling in power, in number, in pride, in absolute dominion over the economy and the society.
”
”
Murray N. Rothbard
β€œ
There can be no socialism without a state, and as long as there is a state there is socialism. The state, then, is the very institution that puts socialism into action; and as socialism rests on aggressive violence directed against innocent victims, aggressive violence is the nature of any state.
”
”
Hans-Hermann Hoppe (A Theory of Socialism and Capitalism: Economics, Politics, and Ethics)
β€œ
No man can rightfully be required to join, or support, an association whose protection he does not desire.
”
”
Lysander Spooner
β€œ
There's a huge swath of humanity that has developed verbal abilities to extract resources from guilt-ridden people. They used to be priests, and now they're leftists.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
There can be no greater stretch of arbitrary power than to seize children from their parents, teach them whatever the authorities decree they shall be taught, and expropriate from the parents the funds to pay for the procedure.
”
”
Isabel Paterson
β€œ
A society that chooses between capitalism and socialism does not choose between two social systems; it chooses between social cooperation and the disintegration of society.
”
”
Ludwig von Mises
β€œ
A cop's JOB is to violently enforce upon the rest of us whatever arbitrary bullshit the political parasites declare to be "law." It is, therefore, impossible to be a "law enforcer" and behave morally, for the same reason one can't be a moral car-jacker.
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
Libertarians make no exceptions to the golden rule and provide no moral loophole, no double standard, for government.
”
”
Murray N. Rothbard
β€œ
The only idea they have ever manifested as to what is a government of consent, is this--that it is one to which everybody must consent, or be shot.
”
”
Lysander Spooner
β€œ
When poverty declines, the need for government declines, which is why expecting government to solve poverty is like expecting a tobacco company to mount an aggressive anti-smoking campaign.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
SCREW CHILDREN! That's the mantra of the world. Instead of burying them with a national debt, shoving them in shitty schools, drugging them if they don't comply, hitting them, yelling at them, indoctrinating them with religion and statism and patriotism and military worship, what if we just did what was right for them? The whole world is built on "screw children", and if we changed that, this would be an alien planet to us.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
No one has the right to place one human being in a position of political power over another.
”
”
Wendy McElroy
β€œ
No man owns me. All man can do is practice the timeless, criminal art of threatening to separate my soul from her physical host.
”
”
Tiffany Madison
β€œ
People are naturally born as Libertarians till governments and oppressive societies force them to adopt their ideologies and their ways.
”
”
Hany Ghoraba
β€œ
Just as war is the natural consequence of monopoly, peace is the natural consequence of liberty.
”
”
Gustave de Molinari
β€œ
If you're rational you don't get to believe whatever you want to believe.
”
”
Michael Huemer
β€œ
The vast majority of people are unthinking prejudice machines.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
Socialism, or communism as it is sometimes called, is merely a secular religion, where the State becomes a god.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
The paralysis of potential is essential to the manufacturing of victims.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
The safest way to make laws respected is to make them respectable.
”
”
FrΓ©dΓ©ric Bastiat
β€œ
Give a man a fish, and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish, and you feed him for a lifetime. Steal a fish from one guy and give it to another--and keep doing that on a daily basis--and you'll make the first guy pissed off, but you'll make the second guy lazy and dependent on you. Then you can tell the second guy that the first guy is greedy for wanting to keep the fish he caught. Then the second guy will cheer for you to steal more fish. Then you can prohibit anyone from fishing without getting permission from you. Then you can expand the racket, stealing fish from more people and buying the loyalty of others. Then you can get the recipients of the stolen fish to act as your hired thugs. Then you can ... well, you know the rest.
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
The man who is not permitted to own is owned.
”
”
George Santayana
β€œ
Accepting necessary conflicts for the sake of improving the lives of children is the only fundamental moral crusade that matters.
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
I think that the Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing the role of government.
”
”
Milton Friedman
β€œ
It was Thomas Edison who brought us electricity, not the Sierra Club. It was the Wright brothers who got us off the ground, not the Federal Aviation Administration. It was Henry Ford who ended the isolation of millions of Americans by making the automobile affordable, not Ralph Nader. Those who have helped the poor the most have not been those who have gone around loudly expressing 'compassion' for the poor, but those who found ways to make industry more productive and distribution more efficient, so that the poor of today can afford things that the affluent of yesterday could only dream about.
”
”
Thomas Sowell
β€œ
If any man's money can be taken by a so-called government, without his own personal consent, all his other rights are taken with it; for with his money the government can, and will, hire soldiers to stand over him, compel him to submit to its arbitrary will, and kill him if he resists.
”
”
Lysander Spooner
β€œ
I feel ashamed that so many of us cannot imagine a better way to do things than locking children up all day in cells instead of letting them grow up knowing their families, mingling with the world, assuming real obligations, striving to be independent and self-reliant and free.
”
”
John Taylor Gatto
β€œ
I didn't know I was a slave until I found out I couldn't do the things I wanted.
”
”
Frederick Douglass
β€œ
Dear Anarcho-Communist, If you and I ever find ourselves in a stateless society, have no fear. Just mention that you are a communist, and I promise I will never try to "oppress" and "exploit" you by offering to trade with you, or by offering to pay you to do work. Sincerely, Larken Rose
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
It isn't a coincidence that governments everywhere want to educate children. Government education, in turn, is supposed to be evidence of the state's goodness and its concern for our well-being. The real explanation is less flattering. If the government's propaganda can take root as children grow up, those kids will be no threat to the state apparatus. They'll fasten the chains to their own ankles.
”
”
Llewellyn H. Rockwell Jr.
β€œ
And, indeed, what is the State anyway but organized banditry? What is taxation but theft on a gigantic, unchecked, scale? What is war but mass murder on a scale impossible by private police forces? What is conscription but mass enslavement? Can anyone envision a private police force getting away with a tiny fraction of what States get away with, and do habitually, year after year, century after century?
”
”
Murray N. Rothbard (For a New Liberty: The Libertarian Manifesto (LvMI))
β€œ
I wonder how many such men in America would know that Communism, the New Deal, Fascism, Nazism, are merely so-many trade-names for collectivist Statism, like the trade-names for tooth-pastes which are all exactly alike except for the flavouring.
”
”
Albert Jay Nock
β€œ
If the bulk of the public were really convinced of the illegitimacy of the State, if it were convinced that the State is nothing more nor less than a bandit gang writ large, then the State would soon collapse to take on no more status or breadth of existence than another Mafia gang.
”
”
Murray N. Rothbard (The Ethics of Liberty)
β€œ
If you personally advocate that I be caged if I don't pay for whatever "government" things YOU want, please don't pretend to be tolerant, or non-violent, or enlightened, or compassionate. Don't pretend you believe in "live and let live," and don't pretend you want peace, freedom or harmony. It's a simple truism that the only people in the world who are willing to "live and let live" are voluntaryists. So you can either PRETEND to care about and respect your fellow man while continuing to advocate widespread authoritarian violence, or you can embrace the concepts of self-ownership and peaceful coexistence, and become an anarchist.
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
Money is not an invention of the state. It is not the product of a legislative act. Even the sanction of political authority is not necessary for its existence. Certain commodities came to be money quite naturally, as the result of economic relationships that were independent of the power of the state.
”
”
Carl Menger
β€œ
Producing laws is not an easier job than producing cars and food, so if the government is incompetent to produce cars or food, why do you expect it to do a good job producing the legal system within which you are then going to produce the cars and the food?
”
”
David D. Friedman
β€œ
A man who chooses between drinking a glass of milk and a glass of a solution of potassium cyanide does not choose between two beverages; he chooses between life and death. A society that chooses between capitalism and socialism does not choose between two social systems; it chooses between social cooperation and the disintegration of society. Socialism is not an alternative to capitalism; it is an alternative to any system under which men can live as human beings.
”
”
Ludwig von Mises
β€œ
It is impossible for us to make any real advance until we take to heart this great truth, that without freedom of choice, without freedom of action, there are not such things as true moral qualities; there can only be submissive wearing of the cords that others have tied round our hands.
”
”
Auberon Herbert
β€œ
My take on socialism is this: Socialism only seems to work when you don't fully implement it, when you keep enough capitalism around to pay socialism's bills, at least for a time. It's the difference between milking the cow and killing it. Socialism has no theory of wealth creation; it's just a destructive, envy-driven fantasy about redistributing it after something else (and somebody else) creates it first.
”
”
Lawrence W. Reed
β€œ
But who would build the roads if there were no government? You mean to tell me that 300 million people in this country and 7 billion people on the planet would just sit around in their houses and think β€œGee, I’d like to go visit Fred, but I can't because there isn’t a flat thing outside for me to drive on, and I don’t know how to build it and the other 300 million or 7 billion people can’t possibly do it because there aren’t any politicians and tax collectors. If they were here then we could do it. If they were here to boss us around and steal our money and really inefficiently build the flat places, then we would be set. Then I would be comfortable and confident that I could get places. But I can’t go to Fred’s house or the market because we can’t possibly build a flat space from A to B. We can make these really small devices that enable us to contact people from all over the word that fits in our pockets; we can make machines that we drive around in, but no, we can’t possibly build a flat space.
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
There is nothing virtuous or noble about being "tolerant" of people whose attitudes and behaviors you approve of. If you don't defend the freedom of even those individuals whose attitudes and behaviors you find disgusting, narrow-minded and offensive, then you are not tolerant. To "tolerate" doesn't mean you like it or approve of it; it means only that you ALLOW it to EXIST--i.e., you refrain from violently interfering. The people who look to "government" to FORCE people to be "nice" are not tolerant.
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
To make a contented slave, you must make a thoughtless one. It is necessary to darken his moral and mental vision, and, as far as possible, to annihilate his power of reason. He must be able to detect no inconsistencies in slavery. The man that takes his earnings, must be able to convince him that he has a perfect right to do so. It must not depend upon mere force; the slave must know no Higher Law than his master's will. The whole relationship must not only demonstrate, to his mind, its necessity, but its absolute rightfulness.
”
”
Frederick Douglass
β€œ
Moreover, in the system of criminal punishment in the libertarian world, the emphasis would never be, as it is now, on "society's" jailing the criminal; the emphasis would necessarily be on compelling the criminal to make restitution to the victim of his crime. The present system, in which the victim is not recompensed but instead has to pay taxes to support the incarceration of his own attacker β€” would be evident nonsense in a world that focuses on the defense of property rights and therefore on the victim of crime.
”
”
Murray N. Rothbard
β€œ
Don't give over all of your critical faculties to people in power, no matter how admirable those people may appear to be. Beneath the hero's facade you will find a human being who makes human mistakes. Enormous problems arise when human mistakes are made on the grand scale available to a superhero. And sometimes you run into another problem. It is demonstrable that power structures tend to attract people who want power for the sake of power and that a significant proportion of such people are imbalanced β€” in a word, insane.
”
”
Frank Herbert
β€œ
If you are for gun control, then you are not against guns, because the guns will be needed to disarm people. So it’s not that you are anti-gun. You’ll need the police’s guns to take away other people’s guns. So you’re very pro-gun; you just believe that only the Government (which is, of course, so reliable, honest, moral and virtuous…) should be allowed to have guns. There is no such thing as gun control. There is only centralizing gun ownership in the hands of a small political elite and their minions.ο»Ώ
”
”
Stefan Molyneux
β€œ
The greater the bureaucratization of public life, the greater will be the attraction of violence. In a fully developed bureaucracy there is nobody left with whom one could argue, to whom one could present grievances, on whom the pressures of power could be exerted. Bureaucracy is the form of government in which everybody is deprived of political freedom, of the power to act; for the rule by Nobody is not no-rule, and where all are equally powerless we have a tyranny without a tyrant.
”
”
Hannah Arendt
β€œ
In any society, order is the first need of all. Liberty and justice may be established only after order is tolerably secure. But the libertarians give primacy to an abstract liberty. Conservatives, knowing that "liberty inheres in some sensible object," are aware that true freedom can be found only within the framework of a social order, such as the constitutional order of these United States. In exalting an absolute and indefinable "liberty" at the expense of order, the libertarians imperil the very freedoms they praise.
”
”
Russell Kirk
β€œ
Voting, the be all and end all of modern democratic politicians, has become a farce, if indeed it was ever anything else. By voting, the people decide only which of the oligarchs preselected for them as viable candidates will wield the whip used to flog them and will command the legion of willing accomplices and anointed lickspittles who perpetrate the countless violations of the people’s natural rights. Meanwhile, the masters soothe the masses by assuring them night and day that they β€” the plundered and bullied multitudes who compose the electorate β€” are themselves the government.
”
”
Robert Higgs
β€œ
What makes anyone think that government officials are even trying to protect us? A government is not analogous to a hired security guard. Governments do not come into existence as social service organizations or as private firms seeking to please consumers in a competitive market. Instead, they are born in conquest and nourished by plunder. They are, in short, well-armed gangs intent on organized crime. Yes, rulers have sometimes come to recognize the prudence of protecting the herd they are milking and even of improving its β€˜infrastructure’ until the day they decide to slaughter the young bulls, but the idea that government officials seek to promote my interests or yours is little more than propagandaβ€”unless, of course, you happen to belong to the class of privileged tax eaters who give significant support to the government and therefore receive in return a share of the loot.
”
”
Robert Higgs
β€œ
All laws which can be violated without doing any one any injury are laughed at. Nay, so far are they from doing anything to control the desires and passions of men that, on the contrary, they direct and incite men's thoughts the more toward those very objects, for we always strive toward what is forbidden and desire the things we are not allowed to have. And men of leisure are never deficient in the ingenuity needed to enable them to outwit laws framed to regulate things which cannot be entirely forbidden... He who tries to determine everything by law will foment crime rather than lessen it.
”
”
Baruch Spinoza
β€œ
In the natural sciences, some checks exist on the prolonged acceptance of nutty ideas, which do not hold up well under experimental and observational tests and cannot readily be shown to give rise to useful working technologies. But in economics and the other social studies, nutty ideas may hang around for centuries. Today, leading presidential candidates and tens of millions of voters in the USA embrace ideas that might have been drawn from a 17th-century book on the theory and practice of mercantilism, and multitudes of politicians and ordinary people espouse notions that Adam Smith, David Ricardo, and others exploded more than two centuries ago. In these realms, nearly everyone simply believes whatever he feels good about believing.
”
”
Robert Higgs
β€œ
Go into the London Stock Exchange – a more respectable place than many a court – and you will see representatives from all nations gathered together for the utility of men. Here Jew, Mohammedan and Christian deal with each other as though they were all of the same faith, and only apply the word infidel to people who go bankrupt. Here the Presbyterian trusts the Anabaptist and the Anglican accepts a promise from the Quaker. On leaving these peaceful and free assemblies some go to the Synagogue and others for a drink, this one goes to be baptized in a great bath in the name of Father, Son and Holy Ghost, that one has his son’s foreskin cut and has some Hebrew words he doesn’t understand mumbled over the child, others go to heir church and await the inspiration of God with their hats on, and everybody is happy.
”
”
Voltaire
β€œ
Property taxes' rank right up there with 'income taxes' in terms of immorality and destructiveness. Where 'income taxes' are simply slavery using different words, 'property taxes' are just a Mafia turf racket using different words. For the former, if you earn a living on the gang's turf, they extort you. For the latter, if you own property in their territory, they extort you. The fact that most people still imagine both to be legitimate and acceptable shows just how powerful authoritarian indoctrination is. Meanwhile, even a brief objective examination of the concepts should make anyone see the lunacy of it. 'Wait, so every time I produce anything or trade with anyone, I have to give a cut to the local crime lord??' 'Wait, so I have to keep paying every year, for the privilege of keeping the property I already finished paying for??' And not only do most people not make such obvious observations, but if they hear someone else pointing out such things, the well-trained Stockholm Syndrome slaves usually make arguments condoning their own victimization. Thus is the power of the mind control that comes from repeated exposure to BS political mythology and propaganda.
”
”
Larken Rose
β€œ
Consider the following sequence of cases, which we shall call the Tale of the Slave, and imagine it is about you. 1. There is a slave completely at the mercy of his brutal master’s whims. He is often cruelly beaten, called out in the middle of the night, and so on. 2. The master is kindlier and beats the slave only for stated infractions of his rules (not fulling the work quota, and so on). He gives the slave some free time. 3. The master has a group of slave, and he decides how things are to be allocated among them on nice grounds, taking into account their needs, merit, and so on. 4. The master allows the slave four days on their own and requires them to work only three days a week on his land. The rest of the time is their own. 5. The master allows his slaves to go off and work in the city (or anywhere they wish) for wages. He also retains the power to recall them to the plantation if some emergency threatens his land; and to raise or lower the three-sevenths amount required to be turned over to him. He further retains the right to restrict the slaves from participating in certain dangerous activities that threaten his financial return, for example, mountain climbing, cigarette smoking. 6. The master allows all of his 10,000 slaves, except you, to vote, and the joint decision is made by all of them. There is open discussion, and so forth, among them, and they have the power to determine to what use to put whatever percentage of your (and their) earnings they decide to take; what activities legitimately may be forbidden to you, and so on. 7. Though still not having the vote, you are at liberty (and are given the right) to enter into discussion of the 10,000, to try to persuade them to adopt various policies and to treat you and themselves in a certain way. They then go off to vote to decide upon policies covering the vast range of their powers. 8. In appreciation of your useful contributions to discussion, the 10,000 allow you to vote if they are deadlocked; they commit themselve3s to this procedure. After the discussion you mark your vote on a slip of paper, and they go off and vote. In the eventuality that they divide evenly on some issue, 5,000 for and 5,000 against, they look at your ballot and count it in. This has never yet happened; they have never yet had occasion to open your ballot. (A single master may also might commit himself to letting his slave decide any issue concerning him about which he, the master, was absolutely indifferent.) 9. They throw your vote in with theirs. If they are exactly tied your vote carries the issue. Otherwise it makes no difference to the electoral outcome. The question is: which transition from case 1 to case 9 made it no longer the tale of the slave?
”
”
Robert Nozick (Anarchy, State, and Utopia)