β
It doesn't matter that she shouldn't, that she never would. What matters is that she could, if she wanted. The power to hurt is a kind of wealth.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
One of them says, 'Why did they do it?'
And the other answers, 'Because they could.'
That is the only answer there ever is.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Gender is a shell game. What is a man? Whatever a woman isn't. What is a woman? Whatever a man is not. Tap on it and it's hollow. Look under the shells: it's not there.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
This is the trouble with history. You can't see what's not there. You can look at an empty space and see that something's missing, but there's no way to know what it was.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
The truth has always been a more complex commodity than the market can easily package and sell.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
You have been taught that you are unclean, that you are not holy, that your body is impure and could never harbour the divine. You have been taught to despise everything you are and to long only to be a man. But you have been taught lies.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Weβre only pretending everything is normal because we donβt know what else to do.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
However complicated you think it is, everything is always more complicated than that.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
The only wave that changes anything is a tsunami. You have to tear down the houses and destroy that land if you want to be sure no one will forget you.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Itβs enough for her to know, sitting in there in the dark, that if she really wanted to she could get out. The knowledge is as good as freedom.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Nothing special has happened today; no one can say she was more provoked than usual. It is only that every day one grows a little, every day something is different, so that in the heaping up of days suddenly a thing that was impossible has become possible. This is how a girl becomes a grown woman. Step by step until it is done.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
She listens at doors and around corners. She has always had this habit. A child in danger must learn to pay more attention to the adults than a child loved and cherished.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
They say: only exceptional people can cross the borders. The truth is: anyone can cross, everyone has it in them. But only exceptional people can bear to look it in the eye.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Silence is not power. Itβs not strength. Silence is the means by which the weak remain weak and the strong remain strong. Silence is a method of oppression.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
The way we think about our past informs what we think is possible today.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Have you thought about the evolutionary psychology of it? Men have evolved to be strong worker homestead-keepers, while womenβwith babies to protect from harmβhave had to become aggressive and violent.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
the highest among us arenβt always the wisest,
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Just like a man,β she says. βDoes not know how to be silent, thinks we always want to hear what he has to say, always talking talking talking, interrupting his betters.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
The shape of power is always the same: it is infinite, it is complex, it is forever branching. While it is alive like a tree, it is growing; while it contains itself, it is a multitude. Its directions are unpredictable; it obeys its own laws. No one can observe the acorn and extrapolate each vein in each leaf of the oak crown. The closer you look, the more various it becomes. However complex you think it is, it is more complex than that. Like the rivers to the ocean, like the lightning strike, it is obscene and uncontained.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Power has her ways. She acts on people, and people act on her.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
The world is the way it is now because of five thousand years of ingrained structures of power based on darker times when things were much more violent... But we don't have to act that way now. We can think and imagine ourselves differently once we understand what we 've based our ideas on.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Now they will know,β shouts one woman into Tundeβs camera, βthat they are the ones who should not walk out of their houses alone at night. They are the ones who should be afraid.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
It is a terrible, wretched thing to love someone whom you know cannot love you. There are things that are more dreadful. There are many human pains more grievous. And yet it remains both terrible and wretched. Like so many things, it is insoluble.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
It doesn't matter that she shouldn't, that she never would. What matters is that she could if she wanted. The power to hurt is a kind of wealth.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
When does power exist? Only in the moment it is exercised. To the woman with a skein, everything looks like a fight.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Itβs not a fucking crisis anymore. This is the new reality.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
There is a part in each of us which holds fast to the old truth: either you are the hunter or you are the prey. Learn which you are. Act accordingly. Your life depends upon it.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
The power to hurt is a kind of wealth.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Gender is a shell game. What is a man? Whatever a woman isnβt. What is a woman? Whatever a man is not. Tap on it and itβs hollow. Look under the shells: itβs not there.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
All things, when measured in spans of years, seem simple. But human lives do not occur in years, but slowly, day by day. A year may be easy, but its days are hard indeed.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
And all we have, in the end, are the choices we make.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
It is only that every day one grows a little, every day something is different, so that in the heaping up of days suddenly a thing that was impossible has become possible.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
You canβt solve anyone elseβs life for them. But then, if you see someone struggling with a heavy load, isnβt it forbidden to walk on without helping them?
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
Already there are parents telling their boys not to go out alone, not to stray too far.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
you belong in three places: the place you grew up, the place where you went to college, and the place where the person you love is.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
Fox News would say whatever makes the most people tune into Fox News.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Sometimes itβs good to go to war, just to know you can.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Sometimes I think that God is punishing me. For what we did together. Sometimes I think that my life is a punishment for wanting. And the wanting is a punishment, too.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
Beneath every story, there is another story. There is a hand within the hand...... There is a blow behind the blow.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Even a stone is not the same as any other stone.
There is no shape to anything except the shape it has.
Every name we give ourselves is wrong.
Our dreams are more true than our waking.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
It follows that there are two ways for the nature and use of human power to change. One is that an order might issue from the palace, a command unto the people saying βIt is thus.β But the other, the more certain, the more inevitable, is that those thousand thousand points of light should each send a new message. When the people change, the palace cannot hold.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
It was like being part of a wave of water,β she says. βA wave of spray from the ocean feels powerful, but it is only there for a moment, the sun dries the puddles and the water is gone. Then you feel maybe it never happened. That is how it was with us. The only wave that changes anything is a tsunami. You have to tear down the houses and destroy the land if you want to be sure no one will forget you.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Her anger is still pure and white and electric, but she doesnβt feel the sadness of it at all. Itβs just a thing she heard about once.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
A year may be easy, but its days are hard indeed.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
You canβt be the one that hurts and the one that comforts.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Itβs not for us to worry about the men,β she says. βLet them please themselves, as they always have. If they want to war with each other and to wander, let them go. We have each other. Where you go, I will go. Your people will be my people, my sisters.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
It is hard now, very hard, but the difficulty is familiar.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Itβs a story about the stuff that happens just exactly when you werenβt expecting it; just on that night you thought nothing was going to happen, everything happens.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Itβs been a while since someone last made her laugh. Since she last laughed without deciding beforehand that laughing was the smart thing to do.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
because, honestly, which of us really understands why we do the things we do?
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
no true knowledge is ever reached without pain.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
Men are no longer permitted to vote β because their years of violence and degradation have shown that they are not fit to rule or govern.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Allie says: Are you trying to tell me thereβs literally no right choice here? The voice says: Thereβs never been a right choice, honeybun. The whole idea that there are two things and you have to choose is the problem.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
They laughed as children do when they are thrown high in the air. We are all falling, all the time, from the half-understood past to the unknowable future. The other name for falling without fear is flying.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Future)
β
There are no shortcuts. Not to understanding and not to knowledge. You can't put anyone into a box. Listen, even a stone isn't the same as any other stone, so I don't know where you all think you get off labeling humans with simple words and thinking you know everything you need. But most people can't live that way, even some of the time.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Scott once said to me that you belong in three places: the place you grew up, the place where you went to college, and the place where the person you love is. Iβd add a fourth component to that: the place where you first sought professional psychological help.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
For the earth is filled with violence, and every living thing has lost its way.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
That is how a man speaks. And that is why.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
When the people change, the palace cannot hold.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Bliss was it in that dawn to be alive,β says Tunde in his voiceover report, because heβs been reading about revolution, βbut to be young was very heaven.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
intuition is just like that: sudden and complete, as if there were machinery working behind her eyes that even she has no access to. Clank, thunk.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
If the world didn't need shaking up, why would this power have come alive now?
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Do you think that you are the stars, perhaps? And that I am the moon? I thought you were the moon. But I have been absent, too, you know. I think I have been absent all this time.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
Power has her ways. She acts on people, and people act on her.
When does power exist? Only in the moment it is exercised.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
For this is the heart of the matter: disasters occur where accidents meet character.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Lessons)
β
Allie says: So what, then? What is any of my power worth if I can't use it here?
The voice says: Remember what Tatiana says. We don't have to ask what they'd do if they were in control. We've seen it already. It's worse than this.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
They have said to you that man rules over woman as Jesus rules over the Church. But I say unto you that woman rules over man as Mary guided her infant son, with kindness and with love.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
The thing about the Lexington International Bank ladder was that it was very long, and climbing it was very exhausting, and so Andrew Brown didn't have a lot of time to think about whether he really wanted to get to the top of itβand besides, since so many other people were climbing too, the view from the top must be worth it.
So he kept going. He worked hard. He put his heart and mind and soul into it. There was an opening for a position half a rung higher than he already was. With a promotion, he might get two hours a week of a secretary's time. He'd go to more important meetings, with more senior people, and have the opportunity to impress them, and if he did he might be promoted again and then... well, of course eventually he'd be running the whole office. It's important to have a dream: otherwise you might notice where you really are.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Doctor Who: Borrowed Time)
β
There is a noise that is different to grief. Sadness wails and cries and lets loose a sound to the heavens like a baby calling for its mother. That kind of noisy grief is hopeful. It believes that things can be put right, or that help can come. There is a different kind of sound to that. Babies left alone too long do not even cry. They become very still and quiet. They know no one is coming.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
People make what they need for themselves,β says Roxy. βMy dad says that. If thereβs something you need, something you really have to haveβnot just want to but have to, youβll find a way to get it.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
For a man to follow you, it must seem that you are the one who knows the way out. Every person is in a dark place. Every person wants to feel that some other man has found the road back into the light.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Liars' Gospel)
β
Have you thought about the evolutionary psychology of it? Men have evolved to be strong worker homestead-keepers, while women - with babies to protect from harm - have had to become aggressive and violent. The few partial patriarchies that have ever existed in human society have been very peaceful places.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
The only thing itβs like is the Gutenberg print revolution and that was followed by four hundred years of bloody war. Suddenly, people were exposed to so much more information than ever before. They had no systems to process it or to tell truth from lies. They were overwhelmed. Thatβs where we are. And humanity doesnβt have time for four hundred years of bloody war right now. There are so many emergencies to deal with.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Future)
β
But all these were not the true religion. For the true religion is love, not fear. The strong mother cradling her child: that is love and that is truth. The girls pass this news from one, to the next, to the next. God has returned, and Her message is for us, only us.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
There are strange movements rising now, not only across the world, but right here in the U.S. of A. You can see it on the internet. Boys dressing as girls to seem more powerful. Girls dressing as boys to shake off the meaning of the power, or to leap on the unsuspecting, wolf in sheepβs clothing.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Your whole question is the mistake. Who's the serpent and who's the Holy Mother? Who's bad and who's good? Who persuaded the other one to eat the apple? Who has the power and who's powerless? All of these questions are the wrong question.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
The most persistent hauntings are the ghosts of lost futures.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Future)
β
I am never going to know how to live without a community of purpose. I am going to keep looking for this for the rest of my life, whatever happens.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Future)
β
This is the pattern of the rule of salt. Imagining bad futures creates fear and fear creates bad futures
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Future)
β
The future calls us on one painful step at a time and the first rule of life is to survive.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Future)
β
He feels excited. He feels ashamed. He wants to talk to her, but he is afraid. Maybe he imagined it all. Maybe she will call him a bad name if he asks her what happened.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
One of them says, βWhy did they do it, Nina and Darrell?β And the other answers, βBecause they could.β That is the only answer there ever is.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
You canβt put anyone into a box. Listen, even a stone isnβt the same as any other stone, so I donβt know where you all think you get off labelling humans with simple words and thinking you know everything you need. But most people canβt live that way, even some of the time.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
They come to ask for her teachings.
They say, "Why do you call God 'She'?"
Eve says, "God is neither woman nor man but both these things. But now She has come to show us a new side to Her face, one we have ignored for too long."
They say, "But what about Jesus?"
Eve says, "Jesus is the son. But the son comes from the mother. Consider this: which is greater, God or the world?"
They say, for they have learned this already from the nuns, "God is greater, because God created the world."
Eve says, "So the one who creates is greater than the thing created?"
They say, "It must be so."
Then Eve says, "So which must be greater, the Mother of the Son?
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
The women will die just as much as the men will if we bomb ourselves back to the Stone Age.
And then we'll be in the the Stone Age.
Er. Yeah.
And then there will be five thousand years of rebuilding, five thousand years where the only thing that matters is: can you hurt more, can you do more damage, can you instill fear?
Yeah?
And then the women will win.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
But itβs more complicated than you think, how you feel about a person. Sometimes I think that if sheβd asked me, even once, to stay, I would have stayed forever. The Rabbis teach that we each hold worlds within us. Maybe both these things are true. But she never asked. And so I had to leave.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (Disobedience)
β
Andβwho can say why these things happen on Thursday, when the same events might have gone unremarked on Tuesday?βthey fought back. A dozen women turned into a hundred. A hundred into a thousand. The police retreated. The women shouted; some made placards. They understood their strength, all at once.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Unfortunately these days quite a lot of people on the internet seem happy to live by the rule of salt. Thatβs a rule of infinite vendetta: scroll back years through a social media timeline, the worst thing you can find another person has done is totally legit to do to them. But then, thatβs the worst thing youβve done, and itβs legit to do it to you. And on and on, everyone trapped inside
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Future)
β
The shape of power is always the same; it is the shape of a tree. Root to tip, central trunk branching and re-branching, spreading wider in ever-thinner, searching fingers. The shape of power is the outline of a living thing straining outward, sending its fine tendrils a little further, and a little further yet.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Tunde tries to imagine what it'd be like to have one. A power you can't give away or trade. He feels himself yearning for it, repulsed by it. He reads online forums where men say that if all the men in the world had one everything would be back to the way it ought to be. They're angry and afraid. He understands that.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
You have been taught that you are unclean, that you are not holy, that your body is impure and could never harbor the divine. You have been taught to despise everything you are and to long only to be a man. But you have been taught lies. God lies within you, God has returned to earth to teach you, in the form of this new power.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
We donβt know much about the culture of Mohenjo-Daroβthere are some findings that suggest that they may have been fairly egalitarian in some interesting ways. But despite the lack of context, the archeologists who unearthed them called the soapstone head illustrated here βPriest King,β while they named the bronze female figure here βDancing Girl.β Theyβre still called by those names. Sometimes I think the whole of this book could be communicated with just this set of facts and illustrations.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
How does trust build between people? It is an offering and a receiving. It is putting yourself into the position to be hurt, just a little, and noticing that they refrain. It is the reaching out between people, laughing at the same moment. It is building a model of the other person inside yourself, placing them in the palm of your hand, rotating them and saying: Yes. I see the flaws and I see the dangers and nothing will happen here that will truly harm me. And it is saying: I would rather trust you than be alone.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Future)
β
There is no safety that does not also restrict us. And many needless restrictions feel safe and comfortable. It is so hard to know, at any moment, the distinction between being safe and being caged. It is hard to know when it is better to choose freedom and fear, and when it is simply foolhardy. I have often, I think, too often erred on the side of caution.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Lessons)
β
Heβs crying a little now, from the shock and the shame and the fear and the humiliation and the pain. Tunde recognizes those feelings; heβs known them since the first day Enuma touched him. He has written in the scribbled notes for his book: βAt first we did not speak our hurt because it was not manly. Now we do not speak it because we are afraid and ashamed and alone without hope, each of us alone. It is hard to know when the first became the second.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
This thing isn't "natural" to us, you know? Some of the worst excesses against men were neverβin my opinion anywayβ perpetrated against women in the time before the Cataclysm. Three or four thousand years ago, it was considered normal to cull nine in ten boy babies. Fuck, there are still places today where boy babies are routinely aborted, or have their dicks "curbed." This can't have happened to women in the time before the Cataclysm. We talked about evolutionary psychology beforeβit would have made no evolutionary sense for cultures to abort female babies on a large scale or to fuck about with their reproductive organs! So it's not "natural" to us to live like this. It can't be. I can't believe it is. We can choose differently.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
It is a dreamer's doctrine. Visionary, astonishing. And a hard road, in times of war and occupation. If all involved had listened to those words, matters would have fallen out quite differently. And if those who claimed to follow him later had dedicated themselves to that one thing- "Love your enemy"- much bloodshed might have been avoided. But perhaps the idea was too difficult, for it is not much observed, even to this day. Easier to prefer one's friend to one's enemy. Easier to destroy than to build or to keep a thing standing.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Liars' Gospel)
β
It turns out the voter's lied. Just like the accusations that they always throw at hard-working public servants, the goddamned electorate turned out to be goddamned liars themselves. They said they respected hard work, commitment and moral courage. They said that the candidate's opponent had lost their vote the moment she gave up on reasoned discourse and calm authority. But when they went into the voting booths in their hundreds, and thousands, and tens of thousands, they'd thought, You know what, though, she's strong. She'd show them.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)
β
Mike used to say: how life happens is a letting in. When he was trying to convince me about the baby. He said every time it was an act of ridiculous trust. The sperm buries itself in the egg and stops being able to move. The egg lets down all its defenses and allows a foreign object in. Thatβs how it happens, every time. An absolutely unjustified leap of faith. Open up, let in, be let in. Opening is dangerous, every single time. But thatβs how weβre here.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Future)
β
The castleβs chapel has been remade. The glass-and-gold chandelier still floats in the center of the room, the wires holding it up too thin to be seen by candlelight. All these electric miracles. The windows depicting the angels praising Our Lady have remained intact, as have the panels to Saint Theresa and Saint Jerome. The othersβand the enameled paintings in the cupolaβhave been replaced and reimagined according to the New Scripture. There is the Almighty speaking to the Matriarch Rebecca in the form of a dove. There is the Prophet Deborah proclaiming the Holy Word to the disbelieving people. Thereβalthough she protestedβis Mother Eve, the symbolic tree behind her, receiving the message from the Heavens and extending her hand filled with lightning. In the center of the cupola is the hand with the all-seeing eye at its heart. That is the symbol of God, Who watches over each of us, and Whose mighty hand is outstretched to both the powerful and the enslaved.
β
β
Naomi Alderman (The Power)