“
The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it.
[These words are also inscribed upon his grave]
”
”
Karl Marx (Eleven Theses on Feuerbach)
“
As we expand our knowledge of good books, we shrink the circle of men whose company we appreciate.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach
“
I would rather be a devil in alliance with truth, than an angel in alliance with falsehood.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas, i.e. the class which is the ruling material force of society, is at the same time its ruling intellectual force. The class which has the means of material production at its disposal, has control at the same time over the means of mental production, so that thereby, generally speaking, the ideas of those who lack the means of mental production are subject to it. The ruling ideas are nothing more than the ideal expression of the dominant material relationships, the dominant material relationships grasped as ideas.
”
”
Karl Marx (The German Ideology / Theses on Feuerbach / Introduction to the Critique of Political Economy)
“
Wherever morality is based on theology, wherever right is made dependent on divine authority, the most immoral, unjust, infamous things can be justified and established.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
For as soon as the distribution of labour comes into being, each man has a particular, exclusive sphere of activity, which is forced upon him and from which he cannot escape. He is a hunter, a fisherman, a herdsman, or a critical critic, and must remain so if he does not want to lose his means of livelihood; while in communist society, where nobody has one exclusive sphere of activity but each can become accomplished in any branch he wishes, society regulates the general production and thus makes it possible for me to do one thing today and another tomorrow, to hunt in the morning, fish in the afternoon, rear cattle in the evening, criticise after dinner, just as I have a mind, without ever becoming hunter, fisherman, herdsman or critic.
”
”
Karl Marx (The German Ideology / Theses on Feuerbach / Introduction to the Critique of Political Economy)
“
God did not, as the Bible says, make man in His image; on the contrary man, as I have shown in The Essence of Christianity, made God in his image.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Lectures on the Essence of Religion)
“
The power of thought is the light of knowledge, the power of will is the energy of character, the power of heart is love. Reason, love and power of will are perfections of man.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
The idea of God is the ignorance which solves all doubt by repressing it.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[T]ruth is considered profane, and only illusion is sacred
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
To theology, ... only what it holds sacred is true, whereas to philosophy, only what holds true is sacred.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Lectures on the Essence of Religion)
“
As individuals express their life, so they are.
”
”
Karl Marx (The German Ideology / Theses on Feuerbach / Introduction to the Critique of Political Economy)
“
The task of the modern era was the realization and humanization of God – the transformation and dissolution of theology into anthropology.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Principles of the Philosophy of the Future (Hackett Classics))
“
Christianity set itself the goal of fulfilling man’s unattainable desires, but for that very reason ignored his attainable desires. By promising man eternal life, it deprived him of temporal life, by teaching him to trust in God’s help it took away his trust in his own powers; by giving him faith in a better life in heaven, it destroyed his faith in a better life on earth and his striving to attain such a life. Christianity gave man what his imagination desires, but for that very reason failed to give him what he really and truly desires.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Lectures on the Essence of Religion)
“
Language is as old as consciousness, language is practical, real consciousness that exists for other men as well, and only therefore does it also exist for me; language, like consciousness, only arises from the need, the necessity, of intercourse with other men.
”
”
Karl Marx (The German Ideology / Theses on Feuerbach / Introduction to the Critique of Political Economy)
“
The joys of theory are the sweetest intellectual pleasures of life
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[Theology is a] web of contradictions and delusions.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Those who suppose they are producing a materialist theory of knowledge when they make knowledge a passive recording and abandon the “active aspect” of knowledge to idealism, as Marx complains in the theses on Feuerbach, forget that all knowledge, and in particular all knowledge of the social world, is an act of construction implementing schemes of thought and expression, and that between conditions of existence and practices or representations there intervenes the structuring activity of the agents, who, far from reacting mechanically to mechanical stimulations, respond to the invitations or threats of a world whose meaning they have helped to produce.
”
”
Pierre Bourdieu (Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste)
“
A circle in a straight line is the mathematical symbol of miracle.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Though I myself am an atheist, I openly profess religion in the sense just mentioned, that is, a nature religion. I hate the idealism that wrenches man out of nature; I am not ashamed of my dependency on nature; I openly confess that the workings of nature affect not only my surface, my skin, my body, but also my core, my innermost being, that the air I breathe in bright weather has a salutary effect not only on my lungs but also on my mind, that the light of the sun illumines not only my eyes but also my spirit and my heart. And I do not, like a Christian, believe that such dependency is contrary to my true being or hope to be delivered from it. I know further that I am a finite moral being, that I shall one day cease to be. But I find this very natural and am therefore perfectly reconciled to the thought.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Lectures on the Essence of Religion)
“
If therefore my work is negative, irreligious, atheistic, let it be remembered that atheism — at least in the sense of this work — is the secret of religion itself; that religion itself, not indeed on the surface, but fundamentally, not in intention or according to its own supposition, but in its heart, in its essence, believes in nothing else than the truth and divinity of human nature.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Hitherto men have always formed wrong ideas about themselves, about what they are and what they ought to be. They have arranged their relations according to their ideas of God, of normal man, etc. The products of their brains have got out of their hands. They, the creators, have bowed down before their creations.
”
”
Karl Marx (The German Ideology / Theses on Feuerbach / Introduction to the Critique of Political Economy)
“
One has to 'leave philosophy aside,' one has to leap out of it and devote oneself
like an ordinary man to the study of actuality . . . Philosophy and the study of the actual world have the same relation to one another as masturbation and sexual love.
”
”
Karl Marx (The German Ideology / Theses on Feuerbach / Introduction to the Critique of Political Economy)
“
The essence of faith … is the idea that that which man wishes actually is: he wishes to be immortal, therefore he is immortal; he wishes for the existence of a being who can do everything which is impossible to Nature and reason, therefore such a being exists[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
To know God and not oneself to be God, to know blessedness and not oneself to enjoy it, is a state of disunity or unhappiness.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Certainly my work is negative, destructive; but … only in relation to the unhuman, not to the human[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Thus, in imagination, individuals seem freer under the dominance of the bourgeoisie than before, because their conditions of life seem accidental; in reality, of course, they are less free, because they are to a greater extent governed by material forces.
”
”
Karl Marx (The German Ideology/Theses on Feuerbach (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Up till now it has been thought that the growth of the Christian myths during the Roman Empire was possible only because printing was not yet invented. Precisely the contrary. The daily press and the telegraph, which in a moment spreads inventions over the whole earth, fabricate more myths (and the bourgeois cattle believe and enlarge upon them) in one day than could have formerly been done in a century.
”
”
Karl Marx (Marx-Engels-Jahrbuch 2003. Die Deutsche Ideologie: Artikel, Druckvorlagen, Entwürfe, Reinschriftenfragmente und Notizen zu "I. Feuerbach" und "II. Sankt Bruno" (German Edition))
“
The law holds man in bondage; love makes him free.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
But certainly for the present age, which prefers the sign to the thing signified, the copy to the original, representation to reality, the appearance to the essence... illusion only is sacred, truth profane. Nay, sacredness is held to be enhanced in proportion as truth decreases and illusion increases, so that the highest degree of illusion comes to be the highest degree of sacredness.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Each planet has its own sun. … [I]t really is another sun on Uranus … The relation of the Sun to the Earth is therefore at the same time a relation of the Earth to itself, or to its own nature … Hence each planet has in its sun the mirror of its own nature.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Consciousness consists in a being becoming objective to itself; … it is nothing apart, nothing distinct from the being which is conscious of itself.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[T]he object of any subject is nothing else than the subject's own nature taken objectively.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
In the object which he contemplates … man becomes acquainted with himself.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
To every religion the gods of other religions are only notions concerning God, but its own conception of God is to it God himself, the true God.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[L]et it be remembered that atheism … is the secret of religion … ; religion … in its heart, in its essence, believes in nothing else than the truth and divinity of human nature.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Feuerbach said, ‘I would rather be a devil in alliance with the truth than an angel in alliance with the falsehood.
”
”
Vlad Kahany (Flowers For The Devil)
“
Ludwig Feuerbach says a wonderful thing about baptism. I have it marked. He says, ‘Water is the purest, clearest of liquids; in virtue of this, its natural character, it is the image of the spotless nature of the Divine Spirit. In short, water has a significance in itself, as water; it is on account of its natural quality that it is consecrated and selected as the vehicle of the Holy Spirit. So far there lies at the foundation of Baptism a beautiful, profound natural significance.’ Feuerbach is a famous atheist, but he is about as good on the joyful aspects of religion as anybody, and he loves the world.
”
”
Marilynne Robinson (Gilead)
“
The consciousness of the infinite is nothing else than the consciousness of the infinity of the consciousness; … in the consciousness of the infinite, the conscious subject has for his object the infinity of his own nature.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Love determined God to the renunciation of his divinity. Not because … God is love, but because of his love, of the predicate, … ; thus love is a higher power and truth[.] Love conquers God. It was love to which God sacrificed his divine majesty. … [W]hat sort of love was that? … [I]t was love to man. … [T]hough there is … a self-interested love among men, still true human love … is that which impels the sacrifice of self to another. Who then is our saviour … ? Love; for God as God has not saved us, but Love, which transcends the difference between the divine and human personality. As God has renounced himself out of love, so we, out of love, should renounce God; for if we do not sacrifice God to love, we sacrifice love to God, and, in spite of the predicate of love, we have the God – the evil being – of religious fanaticism.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
That mention of Feuerbach and joy reminded me of something I saw early one morning a few years ago, as I was walking up to the church. There was a young couple strolling along half a block ahead of me. The sun had come up brilliantly after a heavy rain, and the trees were glistening and very wet. On some impulse, plain exuberance, I suppose, the fellow jumped up and caught hold of a branch, and a storm of luminous water came pouring down on the two of them, and they laughed and took off running, the girl sweeping water off her hair and her dress as if she were a little bit disgusted, but she wasn’t. It was a beautiful thing to see, like something from a myth. I don’t know why I thought of that now, except perhaps because it is easy to believe in such moments that water was made primarily for blessing, and only secondarily for growing vegetables or doing the wash. I wish I had paid more attention to it. My list of regrets may seem unusual, but who can know that they are, really. This is an interesting planet. It deserves all the attention you can give it. In
”
”
Marilynne Robinson (Gilead)
“
Man cannot get beyond his true nature. He may indeed by means of the imagination conceive individuals of another so-called higher kind, but he can never get loose from his species, his nature; the conditions of being, the positive final predicates which he gives to these other individuals, are always determinations or qualities drawn from his own nature – qualities in which he in truth only images and projects himself.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
God as a working hypothesis in morals, politics, or science has been surmounted and abolished; and the same thing has happened in philosophy and religion (Feuerbach!). For the sake of intellectual honesty, that working hypothesis should be dropped, or as far as possible eliminated.
”
”
Dietrich Bonhoeffer (Letters and Papers from Prison)
“
By the word materialism, the philistine understands gluttony, drunkenness, lust of the eye, lust of the flesh, arrogance, cupidity, avarice, covetousness, profit-hunting, and stock-exchange swindling — in short, all the filthy vices in which he himself indulges in private. By the word idealism he understands the belief in virtue, universal philanthropy, and in a general way a “better world”, of which he boasts before others but in which he himself at the utmost believes only so long as he is having the blues or is going through the bankruptcy consequent upon his customary “materialist” excesses. It is then that he sings his favorite song, What is man? — Half beast, half angel.
”
”
Friedrich Engels (Ludwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophy)
“
[T]o a limited being its limited understanding is not felt to be a limitation; on the contrary, it is perfectly happy and contented with this understanding[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[M]an [has] the power of abstraction from himself[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
We know the man by the object[.] Even the moon, the sun, stars, … [t]hat he sees them is an evidence of his own nature.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Whatever kind of object … we are at any time conscious of, we are always at the same time conscious of our own nature[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Wherever this idea, that the religious predicates are only anthropomorphisms, has taken possession of man, there has doubt, has unbelief, obtained mastery of faith.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Philosophers have hitherto only interpreted the world in various ways; the point is to change it
”
”
Karl Marx (Eleven Theses on Feuerbach)
“
Philosophers have hitherto interpreted the world in various way; the point, however, is to change it
”
”
Karl Marx (Eleven Theses on Feuerbach)
“
Philosophers have hitherto interpreted the world in various ways; the point, however, is to change it
”
”
Karl Marx (Eleven Theses on Feuerbach)
“
[T]he present age, which prefers the sign to the thing signified, the copy to the original[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
God as God is feeling … yet shut up, hidden; … Christ is the unclosed, open feeling of the heart. … Christ is the joyful certainty of feeling that its wishes hidden in God have truth and reality, the actual victory over death, over all the powers of the world and Nature, the resurrection no longer merely hoped for, but already accomplished; … the Godhead made visible.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Or how does it happen that trade, which after all is nothing more than the exchange of products of various individuals and countries, rules the whole world through the relation of supply and demand—a relation which, as an English economist says, hovers over the earth like the fate of the ancients, and with invisible hand allots fortune and misfortune to men, sets up empires and overthrows empires, causes nations to rise and to disappear—while with the abolition of the basis of private property, with the communistic regulation of production (and implicit in this, the destruction of the alien relation between men and what they themselves produce), the power of the relation of supply and demand is dissolved into nothing, and men get exchange, production, the mode of their mutual relation, under their own control again?
”
”
Karl Marx (The German Ideology / Theses on Feuerbach / Introduction to the Critique of Political Economy)
“
Faith in the power of prayer … is … faith in miraculous power; and faith in miracles is … the essence of faith in general. … [F]aith is nothing else than confidence in the reality of the subjective in opposition to the limitations or laws of Nature and reason, … The specific object of faith, therefore, is miracle; … To faith nothing is impossible, and miracle only gives actuality to this omnipotence of faith[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Of course, the champions of totalitarianism protest that what they want to abolish is "only economic freedom" and that all "other freedoms" will remain untouched. But freedom is indivisible. The distinction between an economic sphere of human life and activity and a noneconomic sphere is the worst of their fallacies. If an omnipotent authority has the power to assign to every individual the tasks he has to perform, nothing that can be called freedom and autonomy is left to him.
He has only the choice between strict obedience and death by starvation.1
Committees of experts may be called to advise the planning authority whether or not a young man should be given the opportunity to prepare himself for and to work in an intellectual or artistic field. But such an arrangement can merely rear disciples committed to the parrotIike repetition of the ideas of the preceding generation. It would bar innovators who disagree with the accepted ways of thought. No innovation would ever have been accomplished if its originator had been in need of an authorization by those from whose doctrines and methods he wanted to deviate. Hegel would not have ordained Schopenhauer or Feuerbach, nor would Professor Rau have ordained Marx or Carl Menger. If the supreme planning board is ultimately to determine which books are to be printed, who is to experiment in the laboratories and who is to paint or to sculpture, and which alterations in technological methods should be undertaken, there will be neither improvement nor progress. Individual man will become a pawn in the hands of the rulers, who in their "social engineering" will handle him as engineers handle the stuff of which they construct buildings, bridges, and machines. In every sphere of human activity an innovation is a challenge not only to ali routinists and to the experts and practitioners of traditional methods but even more to those who have in the past themselves been innovators.
It meets at the beginning chiefly stubborn opposition. Such obstacles can be overcome in a society where there is economic freedom. They are insurmountable in a socialist system.
”
”
Ludwig von Mises (Theory and History: An Interpretation of Social and Economic Evolution)
“
Religion is the disuniting of man from himself; he sets God before him as the antithesis of himself. … God is … infinite, man … finite … ; God … perfect, man imperfect; … God almighty, man weak; God holy, man sinful.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[S]o much worth … a man has, so much and no more has his God. Consciousness of God is self-consciousness, knowledge of God is self-knowledge. By his God thou knowest the man, and by the man, his God; the two are identical.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
But for the present age, which prefers the sign to the thing signified, the copy to the original, representation to reality, appearance to essence . . . truth is considered profane, and only illusion is sacred. Sacredness is in fact held to be enhanced in proportion as truth decreases and illusion increases, so that the highest degree of illusion comes to be the highest degree of sacredness.” —Feuerbach, Preface to the second edition
of The Essence of Christianity
”
”
Guy Debord (Society of the Spectacle)
“
The sum of productive forces, capital funds and social forms of intercourse, which every individual and generation finds in existence as something given, is the real basis of what the philosophers have conceived as "substance" and "essence of man," and what they have deified and attacked: a real basis which is not in the least disturbed, in its effect and influence on the development of men, by the fact that these philosophers revolt against it as "self-consciousness" and the "Unique.
”
”
Karl Marx (The German Ideology / Theses on Feuerbach / Introduction to the Critique of Political Economy)
“
Nature is precisely what separates man from God … [R]eligion believes that one day this wall of separation will fall away. One day there will be no Nature, no matter, no body, at least none such as to separate man from God: then there will be only God[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Because of … this concentration of all that is universal and real in one personal being, God is a deeply moving object, enrapturing to the imagination; whereas the idea of humanity has little power over the feelings, because humanity is only an abstraction; … God is … a subject; … the perfect universal being as one being, the infinite extension of the species as an all-comprehending unity. But God is only man's intuition of his own nature; thus the Christians … deify the human individual, make him the absolute being.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Man, by means of the imagination, involuntarily contemplates his inner nature; he represents it as out of himself. The nature of man, of the species – thus working on him through the irresistible power of the imagination, and contemplated as the law of his thought and action – is God.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Wherever morality is based on theology, wherever the right is made dependent on divine authority, the most immoral, unjust, infamous things can be justified and established. I can found morality on theology only when I myself have already defined the Divine Being by means of morality. In the contrary case, I have no criterion of the moral and immoral, but merely an unmoral, arbitrary basis, from which I may deduce anything I please. Thus, if I would found morality on God, I must first of all place it in God: for Morality, Right, in short, all substantial relations, have their only basis in themselves, can only have a real foundation—such as truth demands—when they are thus based. (…) Where man is in earnest about ethics, they have in themselves the validity of a divine power. If morality has no foundation in itself, there is no inherent necessity for morality; morality is then surrendered to the groundless arbitrariness of religion.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
So here again we may clearly observe the contrast with the Enlightenment, with which individual commentators have tried to associate Nietzsche because of his atheism. In the Enlightenment, the idea was to prove that belief in God might not signify any kind of moral imperative for mankind, that the moral laws would operate in a society of atheists just as much as in one where religious patronage held sway. Nietzsche, on the contrary, wanted to show that the demise of the idea of God (or the death of God) would entail a moral renaissance in the sense we have noted above. Apart, therefore, from the other ethical contradictions in the ‘old’ and ‘new’ Enlightenment, about which we again already know Nietzsche’s opinion, we find another contrast here in respect of the socio-ethical role of religion. The ‘old’ Enlightenment regarded the religious concept as irrelevant to men’s morality, actions, views etc., which in reality were adequately determined by a combination of society and men’s reason. On the other hand, Nietzsche — and here he far exceeded all Feuerbach’s weaknesses in the realm of historico-philosophical idealism — regarded the switch to atheism as a turning point for morality.
(At this point let us just briefly remark that here Nietzsche’s worldview is very close to certain tendencies in Dostoievsky.)
”
”
György Lukács (Destruction of Reason)
“
Many gnostics, then, would have agreed in principle with Ludwig Feuerbach, the nineteenth-century psychologist, that “theology is really anthropology” (the term derives, of course, from anthropos, and means “study of humanity”). For gnostics, exploring the psyche became explicitly what it is for many people today implicitly—a religious quest. Some who seek their own interior direction, like the radical gnostics, reject religious institutions as a hindrance to their progress. Others, like the Valentinians, willingly participate in them, although they regard the church more as an instrument of their own self-discovery than as the necessary “ark of salvation.
”
”
Elaine Pagels (The Gnostic Gospels (Modern Library 100 Best Nonfiction Books))
“
The main defect of all hitherto-existing materialism — that of Feuerbach included — is that the Object [der Gegenstand], actuality, sensuousness, are conceived only in the form of the object [Objekts], or of contemplation [Anschauung], but not as human sensuous activity, practice [Praxis], not subjectively. Hence it happened that the active side, in opposition to materialism, was developed by idealism — but only abstractly, since, of course, idealism does not know real, sensuous activity as such. Feuerbach wants sensuous objects [Objekte], differentiated from thought-objects, but he does not conceive human activity itself as objective [gegenständliche] activity.
”
”
Karl Marx (Eleven Theses on Feuerbach)
“
Prior to Flew, major apologies for atheism were those of Enlightenment thinkers (David Hume, Arthur Schopenhauer, Ludwig Feuerbach, and Friedrich Nietzsche).
Major philosophers of Flew’s generation who were atheists: W. V. O. Quine and Gilbert Ryle. But none took the step of developing book-length arguments to support their personal beliefs.
In later years, atheist philosophers who critically examined and rejected the traditional arguments for God’s existence: Paul Edwards, Wallace Matson, Kai Nielsen, Paul Kurtz, J. L. Mackie, Richard Gale, Michael Martin. But their works did not change the agenda and framework of discussion the way Flew’s innovative publications did.
”
”
Antony Flew (There Is a God: How the World's Most Notorious Atheist Changed His Mind)
“
Karl Marx’s early (1844) essay On the Jewish Question is a fascinating example of an intellectual form of Jewish self-hatred. He argues that Judaism is neither religion nor people-hood but the desire for gain; totally ignoring the vast Jewish proletariat of Central and Eastern Europe, he equates Jews, and the Christians whose religion derives from them, with the ‘enemy’ – namely, bourgeois capitalism. Clearly, he is fleeing his own Jewish identity (he was baptized at the age of 6, but was descended from rabbis on both sides of the family), ‘assimilating’ to the cultural milieu of the anti-Semitic Feuerbach, whose perverse definition of Judaism he has adopted, and finding refuge from Jewish particularism in socialist universalism.
”
”
Norman Solomon (Judaism: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions Book 11))
“
aussi incontournable. Dans le récit de Foucault en effet, l’entreprise anthropologique se conçoit d’emblée comme une réponse à l’injonction critique. Feuerbach et Dilthey répondent à Kant par une « humanisation » de ces catégories a priori que l’auteur des trois Critiques avait construites à partir des seuls repères de la logique et de la grammaire. Mais l’originaire ou l’essentiel peuvent-ils jouer le rôle d’un transcendantal ? Y a-t-il, dans l’exploration qui entend faire retour vers l’homme originaire, assez pour servir de fondement à l’objectivité scientifique ? La norme d’une essence humaine peut-elle servir de condition de possibilité de la connaissance de l’homme ? On voit aussitôt la circularité : l’homme vrai est la condition de possibilité de la connaissance de l’homme vrai.
”
”
Michel Foucault (La Question anthropologique: Cours, 1954-1955 (French Edition))
“
The link established by Christian theology between oikonomia and history is crucial to an understanding of Western philosophy of history. In particular, it is possible to say that the concept of history in German idealism, from Hegel to Schelling and even up to Feuerbach, is nothing besides an attempt to think the “economic” link between the process of divine revelation and history (adopting Schelling’s terms, which we have quoted earlier, the “co-belonging” of theology and oikonomia). It is curious that when the Hegelian Left breaks with this theological concept, it can do so only on condition that the economy in a modern sense, which is to say, the historical self-production of man, is placed at the center of the historical process. In this sense, the Hegelian Left replaces divine economy with a purely human economy.
”
”
Giorgio Agamben (The Omnibus Homo Sacer (Meridian: Crossing Aesthetics))
“
Man distinguishes himself from Nature. This distinction of his is his God: the distinguishing of God from Nature is nothing else than the distinguishing of man from Nature. … [S]peculations and controversies concerning the personality or impersonality of God are therefore fruitless, idle, uncritical … ; … they in truth speculate only concerning themselves, only in the interest of their own instinct of self-preservation[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[I]t implies great force of subjectivity to accept as certain something in contradiction with rational, normal experience. … Wishes own no restraint, no law, no time; they would be fulfilled without delay on the instant. And behold! miracle is as rapid as a wish is impatient. … [I]t is not in its product or object that miraculous agency is distinguished from the agency of Nature and reason, but only in its mode and process; … The power of miracle is … the power of the imagination.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
The materialist doctrine that men are products of circumstances and upbringing, and that, therefore, changed men are products of changed circumstances and changed upbringing, forgets that it is men who change circumstances and that the educator must himself be educated. Hence this doctrine is bound to divide society into two parts, one of which is superior to society. The coincidence of the changing of circumstances and of human activity or self-change [Selbstveränderung] can be conceived and rationally understood only as revolutionary practice.
”
”
Karl Marx (Eleven Theses on Feuerbach)
“
True love is sufficient to itself; it needs no special title, no authority … [I]t is … the original source of love, out of which the love of Christ himself arose. … Are we to love each other because Christ loved us? Such love would be an affected, imitative love. Can we truly love each other only if we love Christ? … Shall I love Christ more than mankind? Is not such love a chimerical love? … What ennobled Christ was love; … he was not the proprietor of love … The idea of love is an independent idea: I do not first deduce it from the life of Christ; on the contrary, I revere that life only because I find it accordant with the … idea of love.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
The idea of man as a species, and with it the significance of the life of the species, of humanity as a whole, vanished as Christianity became dominant. Herein we have … confirmation … that Christianity does not contain within itself the principle of culture. Where man immediately identifies the species with the individual, and posits this identity as his highest being, as God, where the idea of humanity is thus an object to him only as the idea of the Godhead, there the need of culture has vanished; man has all in himself, all in his God, consequently he has no need to supply his own deficiencies by others as the representatives of the species, or by the contemplation of the world generally; and this need alone is the spring of culture.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[I]n love, man declares himself unsatisfied in his individuality taken by itself, he postulates the existence of another as a need of the heart; … the life which he has through love to be the truly human life, … The individual is defective, imperfect, weak, needy; but love is strong, perfect, contented, free from wants, self-sufficing, infinite; … friendship is a means of virtue, and more: it is … dependent however on participation. … [I]t cannot be based on perfect similarity; on the contrary, it requires diversity, for friendship rests on a desire for self-contemplation. One friend obtains through the other what he does not himself possess. … However faulty a man may be, it is a proof that there is a germ of good in him if he has worthy men for his friends. If I cannot be myself perfect, I yet at least love virtue, perfection in others.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
History is as little able as cognition to reach a final conclusion in a perfect, ideal condition of humanity; a perfect society, a perfect "state," are things which can only exist in the imagination. On the contrary, every successive historical situation is only a transitory stage in the endless course of development of society from the lower to the higher. Each stage is necessary and therefore justified for the time and conditions to which it owes its origin. But it becomes decrepit and unjustified in the face of new, higher conditions which gradually develop in its own womb. It must give way to a higher stage which in its turn will also decay and perish.
”
”
Friedrich Engels (Ludwig Feuerbach And the Outcome of Classical German Philosophy)
“
The world is to be comprehended not as a complex of ready-made things but as a complex of processes, in which apparently stable things no less than the concepts, their mental reflections in our heads, go through an uninterrupted change of coming in to being and passing away, in which, through all the seeming contingency and in spite of all temporary retrogression, a progressive development finally asserts itself.
”
”
Friedrich Engels (Ludwig Feuerbach And the Outcome of Classical German Philosophy)
“
What is now recognized as true also has its hidden false side which will later manifest itself, just as what is now recognized as false also has its true side, by virtue of which it could previously be regarded as true; that what is maintained to be necessary is composed of sheer contingencies, and that the so-called accidental is the form behind which necessity hides itself - and so on.
”
”
Friedrich Engels (Ludwig Feuerbach And the Outcome of Classical German Philosophy)
“
Pensar significa leer en el evangelio de los sentimientos
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach
“
Una assenza momentanea fa bene, perché quando si è presenti le cose sembrano troppo uguali per distinguerle. Persino le torri da vicino hanno proporzioni nanesche, mentre le cose piccole e quotidiane, considerate da vicino, crescono fin troppo. Così è per le passioni. Piccole abitudini le quali con la vicinanza che esse impongono assumono forma appassionata, scompaiono non appena il loro oggetto immediato è sottratto alla vista. Grandi passioni che per la vicinanza del loro oggetto assumono la forma di piccole abitudini, crescono e raggiungono di nuovo la loro proporzione naturale per l'effetto magico della lontananza. Così è con il mio amore. Basta che tu mi sia allontanata solo dal sogno e io so immediatamente che il tempo è servito al mio amore per ciò a cui servono il sole e la pioggia alle piante, per crescere. Il mio amore, appena sei lontana, appare per ciò che è, un gigante in cui si concentra tutta l'energia del mio spirito e tutto il carattere del mio cuore.
Io mi sento di nuovo un uomo, perché sento una grande passione, e la molteplicità in cui lo studio e la cultura moderna ci impigliano, e lo scetticismo con cui necessariamente siamo portati a criticare tutte le impressioni soggettive e oggettive, sono fatti apposta per renderci piccoli e deboli e lamentosi e irrisoluti. Ma l'amore non per l'uomo di Feuerbach, non per il metabolismo di Moleschott, non per il proletariato, bensì l'amore per te, fa dell'uomo nuovamente un uomo.
”
”
Karl Marx
“
Boughton takes a very dim view of him, because he unsettled the faith of many people, but I take issue as much with those people as with Feuerbach. It seems to me some people just go around looking to get their faith unsettled.
”
”
Marilynne Robinson (Gilead (Gilead, #1))
“
Der Religion ist nur das Heilige wahr, der Philosophie ist nur das Wahre heilig.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach
“
Per anni non aveva posseduto molto più dei suoi sogni.
”
”
Simon Feuerbach
“
Recuerda que dijimos que cabía, a grandes rasgos, una antropología espiritualista (Pitágoras, Platón, Plotino, San Agustín, Santo Tomás, Descartes, Leibniz, Fichte, Schelling, Hegel, Husserl, etc.) y una antropología materialista (Leucipo, Demócrito, La Mettrie, D’Holbach, Feuerbach, Marx, Nietzsche, Freud, etc.).
”
”
Vicente Merlo (FILOSOFÍA ¿QUÉ ES ESO?: SABER Y SER EN OCCIDENTE Y ORIENTE (RAZON Y SOCIEDAD nº 129) (Spanish Edition))
“
The power of miracle is the power of imagination.
― Ludwig Feuerbach
The miracle is the supreme reality, a power. Imagination is beyond reality, a powerless illusion.
― Ehsan Sehgal
”
”
Ehsan Sehgal
“
La mort c'est la fin du fini, c'est le commencement de l'infini.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (PENSÉES SUR LA MORT ET L'IMMORTALITÉ)
“
De indivualiteit heeft de plaats ingenomen van het geloof, de rede die van de bijbel, de politiek die van de godsdienst en de kerk, de hemel is door de aarde, het gebed door de arbeid, de hel door de ellende en Christus door de mens vervangen.' De hel zal dan van deze wereld zijn en tegen die wereldse hel zal men moeten strijden.
”
”
Albert Camus (The Rebel)
“
That he is, he has to thank Nature; that he is man, he has to thank man; spiritually as well as physically he can achieve nothing without his fellow-man. Four hands can do more than two, but also four eyes can see more than two. … In isolation human power is limited, in combination it is infinite. The knowledge of a single man is limited, but reason, science, is unlimited, for it is a common act of mankind; … the scientific genius of a particular age comprehends in itself the thinking powers of the preceding age[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
Only through his fellow does man become clear to himself and self-conscious; … A man existing absolutely alone would lose himself without any sense of his individuality in the ocean of Nature; he would neither comprehend himself as man nor Nature as Nature.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[P]ersonal theism conceives God as a personal being, separate from all material things; it excludes him from all development, because that is nothing else than the self-separation of being from circumstances and conditions which do not correspond to its true idea. … [I]n God … beginning, end, middle are not to be distinguished … [H]e is at once what he is, is from the beginning … ; he is the pure unity of existence and essence, reality and idea, act and will. … [T]hey [gods] have bodies like men, but bodies from which the limitations and difficulties of the human body are eliminated.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[T]he effect of the creation, all its majesty for the feelings and the imagination, is quite lost if the production of the world … is not taken in its real sense.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
The creation of the world expressed nothing else than subjectivity, assuring itself of its own reality and infinity through the consciousness that the world is created, is a product of will, … When thou sayest the world was made out of nothing, thou conceivest the world the world itself as nothing, … for the world is the limitation of thy will, … ; the world alone obstructs thy soul; it alone is the wall of separation between thee and God, … ; thou thinkest God by himself, … the subjectivity or soul which enjoys itself alone, which needs not the world, which knows nothing of the painful bonds of matter. In the inmost depths of thy soul thou wouldest rather there were no world, for where the world is, there is matter, and where there is matter there is weight and resistance, space and time, limitation and necessity. … How dost thou expel the world from thy consciousness, that it may not disturb thee … ? [B]y making the world itself a product of will, … hovering between existence and non-existence, always awaiting its annihilation. … [H]ence its end is daily looked forward to with longing.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[M]an … makes Nature merely the servant of his will and needs, and … degrades it to a mere machine, a product of the will. … [I]ts existence is intelligible to him, … he explains and interprets it out of himself, in accordance with his own feelings and notions.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[T]he object to which a subject essentially, necessarily relates, is nothing else than this subject's own … objective nature.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[T]he understanding or the reason is the necessary being. … [I]f there were no reason, no consciousness, all would be nothing; existence would be equivalent to non-existence. Consciousness first founds the distinction between existence and non-existence. In consciousness is first revealed the value of existence, the value of nature.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
The conception of the morally perfect being is no merely theoretical, inert conception, but a practical one, calling me to action, to imitation, throwing me into strife, into disunion with myself; for while it proclaims to me what I ought to be, it also tells me to my face, without any flattery, what I am not. … [R]eligion renders this disunion all the more painful … [I]t sets man's own nature before him as a separate being.
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))
“
[E]very understanding which I posit as different from my own, is only a position of my own understanding, i.e. an idea of my own, a conception which falls within my power of thought, and thus expressed my understanding. … What I think of as united, I unite; what I think of as distinct, I distinguish; … [M]y understanding or my imagination is itself the power of uniting … ; understanding is only the understanding which exists in man[.]
”
”
Ludwig Feuerbach (Essence of Christianity (Great Books in Philosophy))