“
Esther and Rose stare longingly at John Truitt as he stands in his front yard trying a new pipe, an object intended to suggest both his maturity and his masculinity. For Meet Me in St. Louis, this latter quality proved to be particularly urgent: Tom Drake, the actor playing Truitt, never seems convincing as Esther’s boyfriend. (Drake, in fact, was gay.) Hence the movie mobilizes several devices (the pipe, basketball) to “heterosexualize” his character. The pipe, however, remains unlit, and is then tossed aside, implying an impotence confirmed by John’s subsequent behavior: He does not kiss the eager Esther at her party, he nearly misses the trolley, he cancels their date for the Christmas ball. Even when he finally proposes, he leaves Esther in tears, urging her to choose between him and her family. Truitt’s aversion to flame appears most tellingly in the party’s turning-out-the-lights sequence (to which the also gay Minnelli devoted four days), where he not only puts out the Smiths’ lights but Esther’s, too, extinguishing her hopes with a flaccid handshake and hasty departure.
”
”
Robert B. Ray (The ABCs of Classic Hollywood)